The State Of Maharashtra - Free Essay Example

Sample details Pages: 6 Words: 1852 Downloads: 7 Date added: 2017/06/26 Category Law Essay Type Case study Did you like this example? Manoj Mahadev Gawade Vs.The State Of Maharashtra Brief Summary of Facts: Suhas Nadgouda was the Assistant Police Inspector at Miraj Rural Police Station from November 2004 to May 2007. In the morning of 15th June 2006 at 7:30 am Head Constable Kamble informed Suhas that nobody is residing to the call given at the house of Balu Gavade. ASI Koli climbed the roof of the house and saw six person inside the house lying in blood. All were members of the Gaavde family. The following item were sent for forensic examinations from the crime scene: The two wooden logs The five pillows The two gunny bags The quilt having green colour Another quilt having mixed colour Third quilt having red and mixed colour The mat One slipper of right foot Two soil samples Another soil sample Seven other samples of soils The bangle pieces in green and red colour One small wooden piece On 21st June 2006 API Nadgouda searched the house of accused Mahadev Gavade and found the following items in one plastic bag containing: Don’t waste time! Our writers will create an original "The State Of Maharashtra" essay for you Create order A plastic bag containing a half filled white colour pesticide powder in a pack A towel having blue lining, stained with blood One slipper of Paragon company of the left leg having some bloodstains Thorny seeds of Dhattura (Argemone Mexicana) Sessions Court convicted the accused and the appellant has appeled the said order of conviction and sentence. Contention by the Prosecution: Motive is the dispute between accused and deceased. Accused called family members of deceased for the tea party and were last seen with them. They were given Dhattura powder to seatmate them. These seeds were seized under Section 27 of the Evidence Act. Blood stains were found on the cloths of the accused. Right Slipper was found in the house of the accused, while left was in the house of the deceased. Accused mad an extra-judicial confession to Ashok while in jail. Analysis of the Judgement: According to the spot panchanama and seizure panchanama are absolutely silent about the sealing of the articles on the spot thereby giving rise to a strong suspicion that the articles might have been tampered. On the issue of blood stained cloth being seized from the house of the accused, the articled were not properly sealed when they were se ized and therefore they could have been tampered with. In the case of Amarjit Singh Vs. State of Punjab[1], the SC held that the à ¢Ã¢â€š ¬Ã…“à ¢Ã¢â€š ¬Ã‚ ¦..non-sealing of the articles at the spot is a serious infirmity because the possibility of tampering over the said articles cannot be ruled outà ¢Ã¢â€š ¬Ã‚ ¦..à ¢Ã¢â€š ¬Ã‚  The court ruled that since there was infirmity in handling of the evidence, reliance on the results of blood stained cloths cannot be taken. This view of the court seems arbitrary, merely because there was no mention of sealing of articles the panchnama, it is unfair to behalf of the court to deny justice, only on grounds of procedural lapses, substantive injustice is being done in this regard. These are very minor infatuations when taken a holistic view of the facts. All the four accused were found sitting in the courtyard of Malubai (accused No. 1) two days before the incident, they called Balu Gavades wife to offer tea to the persons who ca me visting them. Those guests left the house of Malubai at about 9.15 to 9.30 p.m and on the next day the incident was discovered. According to the Last Seen Theroy, the accused was the last one to see the deceased and therefore is admissible under Section 6 of Indian Evidence act, 1872. Ashok Gavade is the son of deceased Shantabai Gavade stated that there was a property dispute between his family and the accusedà ¢Ã¢â€š ¬Ã¢â€ž ¢s family. One week before the incident his mother Shantabai met with an accident. Manoj who was Laos with them purchased slippers of Paragon Company of blue colour. The statement of Ashok points towards motive of accused admissible under Section 8 of Indian Evidence act, 1872. Mahadev Gavade had sent a letter Ashok and admitted to the conspiracy and told that he will narrated to him when he would come to meet him in jail. It was written his handwriting but no signature. When Ashok went to meet him in the jail, he said he à ¢Ã¢â€š ¬Ã…“committ ed a mistakeà ¢Ã¢â€š ¬Ã‚ . Ashok testified that the handwriting in the letter was of Mahadev. This amounts to extra-judicial confession given by accused and admissible under Section 18 of Indian Evidence act, 1872. Also Ashok views on handwriting is admissible under Section 47 of Indian Evidence act, 1872 as expert opinion. In a case of circumstantial evidence the circumstances on which the prosecution relies must be consistent with the sole hypothesis of the guilt of the accused. They have to form a complete chain and exclude every other suggestion of the innocence. On the issue of motive there are conflicting opinions of both sides. Prosecution claims a property dispute, while the defence claims there was harmony. On the basis of the testimony by Ashok, it is clear that there was no dispute between the said parties as claimed by the prosecution. So motive for the crime is not proved by the prosecution. The very nature of circumstantial evidence is that is gives rise to more than one possibility, it is only a combination of circumstantial evidence must point in one direction, indicial circumstance evident by very nature are suppose give more than one possibility. The court said that since the slipper were found after 4 days of the commission of the crime, reliance on them couldnà ¢Ã¢â€š ¬Ã¢â€ž ¢t be placed. In the Arushi case, the golf club which had blood stains on it was discovered after almost six month of the commission of the crime, but the court still relied on the evidence and higher courts have uptake that evidence. The court held that since no efforts were made as to ascertain whether the slipper found on the crime scene was actually fitting the accused or not. This was again an oversight by the trial court and the high court failed to correct this error. The court also disagreed the slipper evidence that was available, it ruled that since there is a possibility that this kind of slipper can be with anyone, and it is not an exclu sive product with the accused. This evidence was further weakened by Ashok turning hostile and denying that any purchase of the said slipper was done by the accused. At this point the court opined that since there are more than one possibility, reliance on slipper evidence cannot be placed. The court here again confused the total effect of circumstantial evidence, and individual effect of circumstance evanescence. Ashok under cross-examination said that he did not slipper as claimed by the prosecution, he did not say anything on the spot as claimed by the prosecution, he did not state any suspected person as claimed by the prosecution, he doesnà ¢Ã¢â€š ¬Ã¢â€ž ¢t remember Mahadev buying a slipper as claimed by the prosecution, he also said there was no property dispute between the two families. This is a case of witness turning hostile. On the issue of the extra-judicial confession by the accused when he met Ashok in the jail cell, the court ruled that, the statement given to Ashok was an exculpatory statement, it not only exculpates the accused but shifts the burden of crime on Malubai (accused No. 1). The court relied on Pakala Narayanswami Vs. Emperor[2] à ¢Ã¢â€š ¬Ã…“à ¢Ã¢â€š ¬Ã‚ ¦..confession as used in the Evidence Act cannot be construed as meaning a statement by an accused suggesting the inference that he committed the crime. A confession must either admit in terms the offence, or at any rate substantially all the facts which constitute the offence. A statement that contains self-exculpatory matter cannot amount to a confession, if the exculpatory statement is of some fact, which if true, would negative the offence alleged to be confessedà ¢Ã¢â€š ¬Ã‚ ¦Ãƒ ¢Ã¢â€š ¬Ã‚ ¦Ãƒ ¢Ã¢â€š ¬Ã‚ ¦Ãƒ ¢Ã¢â€š ¬Ã‚  The High Court here failed to give reason for why the stamen made to Ashok was an exculpatory statement, there was nothing on the record in the judgement to point towards the exact nature of statement made by the accused. The accused confess ed to a conspiracy in a postcard to Ashok, when he invited him to visit him in jail. He implicated himself and the accused no. 1 in the case, but there is nothing on the record to show what exact stamen was made by the accused to Ashok in the jail cell. However, the court could have admitted the postcard as an admission, if not as confession, but the court threw out both the statement to Ashok and the postcard as exculpatory statement. The court was erroneous in its decision. Dr. Bapusaheb Satpute is the Medical officer in Government Medical College, Miraj The doctor stated that death occurred within four hours after the last meals and the cause of death was cardio respiratory arrest subdural severe haemorrhage due to severe head injury. In the cross-examination he stated that he has further admitted that in case of poisoning he can gather the smell of the said he has no idea about Argemone Mexicana is called as Dhattura and its symptoms in the case of consumption and he di d not refer any material with regards to Argemone Mexicana, but the prosecution claimed that the members of the deceased family were sedated by Dhattura. Dr. Archana Sawant who conducted autopsy on other deadened said that Argemone Mexicana is a toxic substance, has bitter taste which leads to dryness in throat, dim vision, vomiting and headache, dilation of pupils, restlessness. She did not notice any vomitus on the sari or blouse of the dead body of Shantabai. She admitted that heart, lungs, and internal organs would be more congested if Dhattura was given. All the other doctors who conducted autopsy on the deceased, all opined on the same lines as Dr. Archanca. All the medical evidence is admissible as expert opinion under Section 45 of Indian Evidence act, 1872. Now Prosecution has argued that the accused invited the family member for a tea party and thus gave them Dhattura to sedate them and kill them easily. No traces of Dhattura or its effect was found on the bodies of the deceased. All the medical officers testified that there no effects like dryness in throat, dim vision, vomiting and headache, dilation of pupils, restlessness in any of the deceased. The prosecution failed to establish the link between the Dhattura and the crime committed. The Bombay High Court allowed the Criminal Appeals and set aside the conviction and sentence of the appellants. The decision was erroneous in law. The court ignored evidence which was pointing towards the guilt of the accused but the court choose to look the other way. The court did not placed reliance on the motive issue on account of witness turning hostile, the slipper evidence because the slipper evidence was circumstantial, the blood stained cloth because of a procedural lapse by the police which was very minor, and the biggest blunder, the throwing ways of a confession based on no hard evidence or justification by the court. cASE COMMENT ON Manoj Mahadev Gawade Vs.The State of Maharashtra [1] (1993) CCR 486 (SC) [2] MANU/PR/0001/1939 : AIR 1939 P.C. 47

Empathy Is An Essential Part Of Being A Successful Leader

Empathy is an essential part in being a successful leader. It is part of his or hers internal and core elements of character. In this essay, I will include excerpts from ADRP 6-22, Delores Pressley, and John Baldoni. Pressley and ADRP 6-22 touches on how positively empathy work when leaders connect with their subordinates. John Baldoni’s article, â€Å"How to Lead with Empathy (and When Not To)†, touches on some of the negative aspects when empathy becomes sympathy. A good leader will recognize the difference between the two, and will be effective when understanding his or her subordinates, make sound choices, and provide guidance to make that individual successful. The dictionary definition of Empathy is the psychological identification with or vicarious experiencing the feelings, thoughts, and attitudes of others. Simply put, empathy is the ability to step into someone else’s shoes, be aware of their feelings and understand their needs. In the workplace, empathy can show a deep respect for co-workers and show that you care, as opposed to just going by rules and regulations. An empathic leadership style can make everyone feel like a team and increase productivity, morale and loyalty. Empathy is a powerful tool in the leadership belt of a well-liked and respected executive (Pressley, 2012). Army leaders show empathy when they genuinely relate to another person’s situation, motives, and feelings. Empathy does not necessarily mean sympathy for another,Show MoreRelatedEmotional Intelligence and Empathy in Leadership Essay example1702 Words   |  7 Pagesin the following studies that higher level education is lacking in regard to the study of emotional intelligence and empathy within their business leadership programs. Empathy is defined as, â€Å"the feeling that you understand and share another persons experiences and emotions: the ability to share someone elses feelings,† (Merriam-Webster, 2014). Emotional intelligence and empathy will be observed throughout this paper as a result of two separate studies, each were conducted with regard to leadershipRead MoreMy Vision For The Future Of Psychiatric Care797 Words   |  4 Pagescan spend more time with their patients. Good leaders are the ones that are not too good to learn from their followers. Transformational leadership can be defined as leadership that allows the leaders and the followers to raise each other’s levels of morality and motivation (Drenkard, 2012). You have to work on discovering what motivates the ones you lead. I am open minded enough to be an evolving transformational leader. According to Taylor’s Principles’ of Scientific Management,Read MoreNursing Servant Leadership Paper1349 Words   |  6 PagesAs we develop into leaders, one of the things we need to know is what it means to be a servant leader. Today such examples are greatly lacking. Servant leadership is a choice by a leader to follow the example of The Jesus Christ and The Mother Teresa and lead by serving, becoming a bondservant and giving his life for others. Servant leadership is an inner attitude of the heart by which a person chooses to place himself or herself under the leadershi p of Jesus Christ and Mother Teresa. Christ oftenRead MoreChange From A Top Down Design Essay1349 Words   |  6 Pagesare in the midst of chaos themselves and, even though a best effort is given, solutions fail. I live this scenario in my job as a high school principal. State mandates are created and deadlines are established. District leaders receive information and require school leaders, such as myself, to solve the problem. Unfortunately, district personnel are not involved in the change process and, consequently, this is why the implementation of initiatives fails. Upper management has no connection toRead MoreEffective Communication As A Foundation For Planning1041 Words   |  5 PagesCommunication is significant for Soldiers and leaders in the military so as to perform the basic functions of leadership, i.e., Planning, Organizing, and Leading. Good communication helps leaders perform their duties and holds themselves and their Soldiers accountable for their responsib ilities and actions or inaction. Effective communication serves as a foundation for planning. All the essential information must flow to the leaders who in-turn must communicate the plans so as to implement them.Read MoreLeadership Attributes Of A Leader1036 Words   |  5 Pages Over the past few decades, leaders take an essential role in accordance to success, efficiency, and performance of their staff. There are copious and varied definitions regarding the perception of a leader, in addition to the term leadership. A leader has attributes of character, presence, and intellect. It shapes how an individual behaves and how leaders perform. Leadership attributes are internal to a leader. Not only, have these attributes included a large array of characteristics suchRead MorePurpose And Understanding Of An Authentic Servant Leader1618 Words   |  7 Pagesor the direction of their lives. The purpose and understanding of reflection is important in instruction. Authentic lead ers have a clear understanding of who they are and they lead from their core values (Northouse, 2016). In discovering my core values by following my internal leading in becoming an authentic servant leader (George, 2010), I am able to recognize the importance of being self-aware, relational, supportive, and participatory with the ability to manage crisis (Northouse, 2016). I struggleRead MoreProject Manager1358 Words   |  6 Pagesthe report. There will also be the case study and analyzing if the project manager in the case study is a good or bad manager. In the first part of the main body, the report will discuss about the quality of the project manager from communication skills, enthusiasm and empathy. The competencies and managerial effectiveness will come after that. In this part we will see from the aspect of goal setting, human resource management, and delegating task, time planning and budgeting. After that, it willRead MoreThe Transformational Journey Of Leadership1652 Wor ds   |  7 Pagesâ€Å"Leadership is unlocking people’s potential to become better.† –Bill Bradley The transformational journey of leadership is marked by personal growth and development. Once you become a leader, success in the area of leadership is characterized by your ability to assist others in their own personal growth and development. As a child, nascent experiences shaped my values around selflessness and the intrinsic ability to empower myself and others to reach optimal potential. My greatest desire has alwaysRead MorePossession Of Emotional Intelligence As An Essential Component For Effective Leadership1358 Words   |  6 PagesPossession of emotional intelligence is an essential component for every effective leader in whatever capacity. The ability for a leader to comprehend and manage his or her emotions and of the people close to them is critical in good leadership. As outlined by Kotter, good leadership needs â€Å"motivating and inspiring,† in other words, keeping individuals moving in the appropriate direction, in spite of significant obstacles to change, through appealing to elementary, but untapped human values, needs

Peace Building in West Pokot Free Essays

Abstract Peace and stability are significant components of development in all spheres across the globe. These necessitated the emergence and growth of peace building and conflict management efforts world over. However, conflict related challenges continue to threaten the survival and continued existence of many groups, communities, states and regions in the world. We will write a custom essay sample on Peace Building in West Pokot or any similar topic only for you Order Now In Kenya, an analysis of West Post Sub-county reveals the existence of multiple intervention efforts by the Government and several stakeholders In peace building and conflict management. However, little has been achieved so far as a result of these efforts. This study therefore examined peace building and conflict management programs In West Post Sub-county wealth the Republic of Kenya, and the residents’ perceptions on the effectiveness of these programs In the Sub-county. Its Justification was based on an argument that West Post conflicts have had far reaching consequences to the residents of this study area and country at large. This study further focused on the Post-Turban conflicts and the subsequent peace building and conflict management initiatives in the area. Based on the outcome of this study, there were several peace building and conflict management programs in West Post Sub-county, many of which were carried out concurrently. Disarmament program was found to be unpopular with majority of respondents expressing disapproval due to its involvement of force and brutality, while the peace committee model was highly rated with most of the respondents approving it as largely inclusive. In conclusion, the Government should adopt a holistic approach that incorporates all approaches and stakeholders, especially the local communities. In addition, the Government should also address social issues that escalate conflicts. How to cite Peace Building in West Pokot, Papers

Crazy World by Boys Like Girls free essay sample

After a two-year hiatus, Boys Like Girls is back with â€Å"Crazy World.† This upbeat, pop-rock band creates music that will definitely get you dancing. Their fast-paced music will instantly put you in a good mood. With inspirational lyrics and catchy tunes, this album suits a variety of tastes. â€Å"Crazy World,† experiments with various styles, including country and soul. â€Å"Be Your Everything,† â€Å"Hey You,† and â€Å"Leaving California† are slow and convey sadness without being boring. The lyrics can be compared to a love poem. However, Boys Like Girls also creates music for having fun and dancing. â€Å"Shoot,† â€Å"The Life of the Party,† and â€Å"Crazy World† really get you into an excited mood. The guitar, drums, and piano blend together perfectly to accompany the lyrics. Band members Martin Johnson, Paul DiGiovanni, Morgan Dorr, and John Keefe write all their own music. Based on personal issues, their music conveys emotion and heart. For example, Johnson, lead vocalist and guitarist, wrote â€Å"On Top of the World† about his mother who passed away. We will write a custom essay sample on Crazy World by Boys Like Girls or any similar topic specifically for you Do Not WasteYour Time HIRE WRITER Only 13.90 / page Boys Like Girls popularity started with the release of their first, self-titled album, which sold over 580,000 copies in the United States. They performed on radio shows and opened for artists including Avril Lavigne and We the Kings. Continuing with their success, Boys Like Girls debuted their second album, â€Å"Love Drunk.† Iconic and catchy songs such as â€Å"Love Drunk† and â€Å"Two Is Better Than One† caught the attention of many teenagers. Along with their recent single, â€Å"Crazy World,† â€Å"Love Drunk† earned a spot on the Billboard 200. Boys Like Girls creates feel-good, catchy songs for our generation. This band understands our situations and writes music to soothe our problems, but their main point is to have fun and love life. Their music is a refuge for teenagers and appeals to a variety of tastes. We might live in a crazy world, but lets focus on having fun.